“Ordinary meals are unusually delicious” at this “cool”, “reasonably priced” all-day New American BYO “institution” that resembles a “delightful old soda parlor” with a “hopping” patio attached; it’s practically “the center of social life in Montclair”, which translates to “loud noise” inside and “long lines outside”, “especially on summer weekends”- but that’s part of the “fun.”